by Rubellan » Sun Sep 10, 2006 5:22 am
The original Haysi CD was not entirely from masters, and suffered from terrible sound quality. Many of the songs run together on the album, yet that CD let you hear the sound engineer turn the tape machine off, then back on. Sound was muddy on many tracks, bad fades, bad starts, poor vinyl remasters for various bonus tracks - it was one of the worst CD's I've ever heard. I parted with it soon after purchasing.
Regarding Cherry Red and vinyl remasters - I have been the most outspoken against it. The truth of the matter is they just don't care. Yes, they could obtain the original masters, as per the license agreements, and have with high quality reissues they've previously released; i.e. the first two Classix Nouveaux CD's and the Landscape CD. At this point they are CHOOSING not to obtain masters, as it is generally cheaper and easier to drop a needle on a record and call it art. The guy they have doing their remastering is absolutely awful, hence the limitations you mention in your post. He spits out over 30 masters for Cherry Red a month, and with that pace there is no time to bring quality when remastering from vinyl. The only reason I am doing some of their remasters is to prevent disappointment for albums I love. As many have heard me state, it takes me several days to weeks to complete a single master, as I do everything manually. Regardless of how good anyone's vinyl remastering skills are, I would gladly prefer master sources any day (as I was able to do with the latest Toyah CD), however it is not an option (for me), and not in my control. I have typed myself raw trying to get Cherry Red to realize the importance of tapes, though it's just not resonating. The Haysi CD was one of many recommendations I suggested to them last year. They have been turned down for many of the titles already, though others are still awaiting a response. In truth, I would not have bothered making the suggestions if I knew they were going to drop using studio masters altogether because I can make my own CD from vinyl and leave it at that. Now that I know how things are being done there nowadays, I don't intend to suggest any further titles for them to release because if they get approved they will be vinyl remasters, and I will do the job purely to prevent another awful sounding release of a great lost album. Just listen to the two 'never released on cd' songs on the recent Darling Buds "Pop Said" reissue. They sound godawful! Dirty, scratchy records, and we know that Sony has the masters.
The new Haysi CD will be a dramtic improvement over the original. Trust me, the master is right next to me. And yes, it does contain the correct version of 'Shiny Shiny' 12" mix.